Plaintiff Personal Injury Pre-Litigation Case Management Supervisor (Miami Lakes. FL)
Job Summary
The Manager of the Senior Case Management Department is responsible for leading, developing, and optimizing a high-performing team of Senior Case Managers focused on negotiating and settling personal injury cases. This role is accountable for ensuring all case management processes are executed effectively, team performance meets or exceeds monthly settlement goals, and operational excellence is maintained across the department.
What You’ll Be Responsible For
Leading and motivating a team of high-volume case managers
Driving monthly settlement results and hitting aggressive targets
Running 1:1s, coaching sessions, and performance check-ins
Holding your team accountable to productivity and quality standards
Monitoring pipeline, projections, and closing performance
Jumping in on escalated client situations and turning them around
Identifying gaps, fixing inefficiencies, and improving workflows
Building structure, developing leaders, and scaling your team
Hiring, training, and leveling up talent
Who You Are
A natural leader who thrives in fast-paced, high-pressure environments
Obsessed with results, accountability, and winning
Experienced in settlement negotiations (2+ years)
Proven track record managing teams and hitting targets (2+ years leadership)
Strong communicator who can coach, challenge, and develop people
Data-driven and comfortable owning performance metrics
Why This Role
You’ll own the outcome—and see the results of your leadership
High-growth environment with real opportunity to advance
Work with a team that moves fast and plays to win
Your impact is direct, visible, and rewarded
Qualifications
Minimum 2+ years of management experience in a performance-driven environment
Minimum 2+ years of experience working in legal industry running a team of Case Managers for settlements and negotiations
Strong leadership, coaching, and team development skills
Excellent communication and interpersonal abilities
Strong analytical and data-driven decision-making skills
Highly organized, proactive, and results-oriented
Ability to manage multiple priorities in a fast-paced environment
Commitment to maintaining high performance standards and accountability
Ability to work collaboratively across departments
Ability to work onsite at our Miami Lakes office (Monday - Friday 8:30 - 5:30 PM)