Underwriter - New York Metro

About the role

The Underwriter is a key member of the underwriting team reporting to the Regional Underwriting Manager. The primary goal of this position is to profitably grow a book of business by actively partnering with Agents and working effectively with colleagues throughout the organization. This person will plan and budget for the book of business, develop and maintain agency relationships, and execute underwriting decisions.

Responsibilities

• Business Management: Review your book of business, track performance, and analyze market conditions and competition.
• Broker Partnership: Build and manage broker relationships, develop goals and strategies, and collaborate to craft tailored solutions for members.
• Underwriting Execution: Oversee new and renewal underwriting, select risks per company guidelines, and ensure timely follow-up and closing of accounts.

Requirements

• At least 3 years of P&C insurance experience, preferably underwriting in the high net worth space.
• Comfortable owning a book of business.
• Direct, empathetic communication skills and a knack for building connections.
• Ability to gather and analyze data to make informed risk decisions.
• Pride and determination in your work.

Who We Are

We are a member-owned property and casualty insurer designed exclusively for financially successful families and driven by a purpose of doing what is right for our members. We provide exceptional service, hospitality and care, partner with our members to help prevent losses, and create smart insurance solutions at fair prices. We aim for our members to love their insurance and for the membership experience to be so compelling that members never want to leave.

What We Expect

• Opportunities to stretch and grow: Professional and personal development is valued through on-the-job learning and development experiences that increase your impact and rewards.
• Clarity and kindness: Expect open, honest, and supportive communication with clear expectations of success.
• Support in good times and bad: We show up for each other consistently, offering thoughtful partnership even when we disagree.
• A community that cares: We sustain a community where each person feels valued, lift each other up, celebrate wins, and support one another through challenges in work and life.

What You Bring

• Aim to bring your best every day and be part of a team that makes a real impact.
• Be a student and a teacher: share your knowledge, listen, and learn from others.
• Get comfortable being uncomfortable: approach tough moments with courage, positivity, and solutions.
• Be a culture builder: foster a positive culture based on care, respect, and openness to diverse perspectives.

Compensation

The base salary for this role ranges from $70,000 to $85,000 on a full-time schedule. An individual’s ultimate compensation will vary depending on job-related skills and experience, geographic location, market data alignment, and equity among comparable team members. Annual merit-based increases and discretionary bonuses are available.